Vassar
 College
 
 
 
Exporting
 a
 National
 Identity
 
Green
 Tea’s
 Entrance
 into
 the
 Gl...
  2
 
Table
 of
 Contents
 
Acknowledgements……………………………………………………………………………………………3
 
1. Introduction:
 a
 cup	...
  3
 
Acknowledgements
 
  First
 of
 all,
 I
 would
 like
 to
 thank
 Professor
 Light
 Carruy...
  4
 
1.
 Introduction:
 a
 cup
 of
 tea
 at
 the
 end
 of
 a
 
meal
 
 
When
 sushi
 ent...
  5
 
Before
 I
 elaborate,
 I
 will
 briefly
 explain
 my
 personal
 motivations
 for
 writing
...
  6
 
commodities
  lose
  what
  Walter
  Benjamin
  would
  call
  their
  cultural
  “aura”
  (19...
  7
 
2.
 Sado:
 the
 Japanese
 tradition
 of
 tea
 
preparation
 as
 a
 class
 culture
 
 
J...
  8
 
grounds
 of
 its
 political
 sovereignty”
 (Surak
 2013:2).
 
 This
 distinction
 of
 cultiv...
  9
 
that
  wasn’t
  just
  a
  deed
  but
  had
  cultural
  significance
  that
  could
  be
...
  10
 
One
  of
  these
  characteristics
  is
  the
  Japanese
  general
  tendency
  towards
 
int...
  11
 
varying
  interpretations
  of
  Zen
  through
  the
  different
  evolutions
  of
  sado,
  ...
  12
 
about
 man
 and
 nature.
 
 It
 is
 hygiene,
 for
 it
 enforces
 cleanliness;
 it
 is
...
  13
 
Over
  time,
  people
  have
  argued
  that
  the
  tradition
  of
  tea
  preparation
  h...
  14
 
2011:176).
 
  By
  possessing
  cultural
  capital,
  the
  upper
  classes
  assume
  domi...
  15
 
foundations
 of
 the
 nation,
 and
 therefore
 it
 was
 their
 duty
 to
 “nourish
 a
 w...
  16
 
are
 the
 ones
 who
 give
 permission
 for
 tea
 ceremonies
 to
 be
 taught.
 
 They
...
  17
 
feminism
  in
  that
  Japanese
  women
  still
  strive
  to
  retain
  their
  “femininenes...
  18
 
perspective,
 many
 would
 not
 view
 women’s
 involvement
 in
 sado
 as
 a
 sufficient
 ...
  19
 
Japanese
  incense,
  which
  now
  occupies
  a
  more
  reclusive
  section
  of
  culture	...
  20
 
So
 why
 do
 many
 consumers
 associate
 green
 tea
 with
 Japanese
 culture
 more
 than	...
  21
 
influenced
  by
  Chinese
  culture
  and
  philosophy.
 
 
  Through
  travel
  to
  Chi...
  22
 
a
 difference.
 
 However,
 China’s
 green
 tea
 omits
 a
 significant
 step
 in
 the
 ...
  23
 
3.
 Bottled
 Tea,
 Instant
 Tea:
 the
 fast
 food
 
movement
 and
 its
 consequences
 
...
  24
 
form
  of
  mechanical
  mass
  production
  allows
  beverage
  corporations
  to
  accurately...
  25
 
mode
  of
  production
  is
  completely
  prescribed,
  there
  is
  no
  room
  for
  inn...
  26
 
canned
  and
  bottled
  forms
  because
  it
  has
  always
  been
  served
  complimentary	...
  27
 
What’s
 more,
 “Market
 researcher
 Inryou
 Souken
 reported
 that
 the
 best-­‐selling
 drin...
  28
 
efficiency
  and
  security.
 
 
  But
  as
  soon
  as
  green
  tea
  entered
  the
...
  29
 
4.
 Raising
 cultural
 consciousness?
 Entrance
 
into
 the
 global
 food
 network
 
 
 ...
  30
 
corporation
  in
  this
  race,
  has
  more
  than
  20,000
  stores
  in
  65
  countries...
  31
 
green
 tea
 in
 this
 latte
 is
 an
 authentic
 ingredient
 comparable
 to
 the
 high
 ...
  32
 
Meanwhile,
 Schultz
 also
 decorated
 the
 interior
 of
 the
 coffeehouses
 in
 natural
 
h...
  33
 
faced
  the
  same
  fate.
 
  While
  it
  still
  retains
  a
  very
  faint
  bittern...
  34
 
the
  more
  people
  continued
  to
  consume
  the
  Starbucks
  experience,
  the
  more
...
  35
 
cultural
 capital
 may
 take
 flight
 and
 inspire
 more
 cultural
 exposure.
 
 However,
...
  36
 
Retail
 tea
 shops
 
While
  large
  corporations
  like
  The
  Coffee
  Bean
  and
  Star...
  37
 
where
  everything
  has
  become
  “packaged”,
  true
  authenticity
  is
  unattainable.
 
...
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
NakagawaSeniorThesis
of 60

NakagawaSeniorThesis

Published on: Mar 3, 2016
Source: www.slideshare.net


Transcripts - NakagawaSeniorThesis

  • 1. Vassar  College       Exporting  a  National  Identity   Green  Tea’s  Entrance  into  the  Global  Food   Network     A  Thesis  submitted  in  partial  satisfaction  of  the  requirements   for  the  degree  Bachelor  of  Arts  in  Sociology       by       Erika  Nakagawa     Thesis  Advisor:   Light  Carruyo             May  2015
  • 2.   2   Table  of  Contents   Acknowledgements……………………………………………………………………………………………3   1. Introduction:  a  cup  of  tea  at  the  end  of  a  meal................................................................4   2. Sado:  the  Japanese  tradition  of  tea  preparation  as  a  class  culture   a. Japan’s   national   identity:   the   influence   of   Sado’s  religious   and   aesthetic   philosophy…………………………………………………………………………………………...7   b. Gender  Discrimination  and  Social  Stratification  in  Modern  Practices……12   c. Japanese  green  tea  vs.  Chinese  green  tea……………………………………………..19   3. Bottled  tea,  Instant  tea:  the  fast  food  movement  and  its  consequences   a. Mechanical  production:  accessibility  and  the  disintegration  of  culture…23   4. Raising  cultural  consciousness?  Entrance  into  the  global  food  network     a. Physical  modes  of  entry:  ……………………………………………………………………29   i. Cafés:  selling  the  experience   ii. Retail  tea  shops   iii. Sado  Tea  Houses   iv. Through  other  foods   b. Perception  in  the  media:  Health  benefits……………………………………………..39   c. Migration  of  bodies  for  tourism…………………………………………………………..40   5. Conflict  in  the  midst  of  global  diffusion   a. Social  Issues………………………………………………………………………………………43   b. Environmental  Issues…………………………………………………………………………46   c. Economic  Issues…………………………………………………………………………………49   6. Conclusion:  food  culture  in  the  face  of  globalization…………………………………52   Bibliography…………………………………………………………………………………………………….57
  • 3.   3   Acknowledgements     First  of  all,  I  would  like  to  thank  Professor  Light  Carruyo,  my  thesis  advisor,   for   patiently   guiding   me   through   the   complicated   molding   of   my   thesis.   Her   suggestions  helped  me  articulate  my  argument  and  drove  me  to  ask  more  questions   in  tracing  green  tea’s  history.    I  am  also  grateful  to  Professor  Pinar  Batur,  who  led   the  thesis  seminar,  for  her  reassuring  guidance  throughout  the  whole  process.    Her   class   on   “Dissent   at   the   end   of   the   Anthropocene”   completely   reshaped   my   conception   of   action   and   finally   helped   me   understand   what   it   means   to   study   sociology.    Many  of  my  friends  also  supported  me  through  long  hours  in  the  library   for  which  I  am  eternally  grateful.        One  of  these  precious  friends  was  Adam  Eichen,   who  not  only  helped  me  keep  my  bearings,  but  also  reminded  me  why  I  am  writing   about  green  tea.    Without  him,  this  thesis  would  have  been  much  more  boring  to   read.    And  finally,  I  would  like  to  thank  my  family  for  all  of  their  support  throughout   the   years,   with   a   special   thanks   to   my   mother   who   encouraged   me   to   follow   my   heart  and  choose  this  topic.        It  has  been  an  amazing  journey.
  • 4.   4   1.  Introduction:  a  cup  of  tea  at  the  end  of  a   meal     When  sushi  entered  the  global  food  market  as  an  exotic  and  luxurious  dish,  a   less   conspicuous   commodity   also   followed   in   its   shadow.     After   satisfying   the   customers  with  the  delicacy  of  sushi,  Japanese  restaurants  will  typically  serve  a  hot   cup  of  bitter  green  tea  as  a  palette  cleanser  and  conclusion  to  the  meal.  Its  mellow   taste  calms  the  consumer  and  instills  a  sense  of  leisure.    Unlike  coffee,  which  is  often   consumed   in   the   United   States   as   an   energy   booster   on-­‐the-­‐go,   green   tea   is   not   meant  to  be  gulped,  it  is  meant  to  be  savored.   But  this  beverage  is  no  complete  novelty  for  the  Western  world  that  has  been   enjoying  black  tea  for  centuries.    In  fact,  green  tea  can  be  considered  as  the  bitterer   sister  of  black  tea.    Yet  green  tea  continues  to  attract  more  consumers  because  of  its   unique   history   and   its   health   benefits,   and   has   found   its   position   in   the   modern   mainstream   through   its   constant   evolutions.     Since   its   beginnings   as   a   tool   for   Buddhist  rituals,  green  tea  has  evolved  with  the  times  and  taken  on  new  identities.     However,  these  adaptations  in  the  face  of  today’s  globalization  have  also  stripped   the  identity  of  the  object  through  commodification.    In  this  thesis,  I  will  follow  green   tea’s   journey   through   its   different   stages   of   consumption   patterns   in   order   to   explore  the  phenomenon  of  cultural  capital  and  its  survival  in  the  global  economy,   as  well  as  the  issues  that  emerge  from  a  commodity’s  global  success.
  • 5.   5   Before  I  elaborate,  I  will  briefly  explain  my  personal  motivations  for  writing   this  thesis  that  will  give   a  more  profound  dimension  essential  to  my  overarching   argument.    Despite  being  born  and  having  grown  up  in  the  United  States,  my  first-­‐ generation  mother  has  always  ensured  that  I  was  exposed  to  my  Japanese  heritage.     Therefore,   I   have   always   had   an   ineffable   affinity   towards   Japan   and   its   culture.       Even   though   I   consider   myself   American,   Japan   also   feels   like   home   whenever   I   return  to  it,  and  when  I  visit  a  Japanese  grocery  store  in  the  States,  there’s  always  a   feeling  that  I  can  only  best  describe  as  “belonging”.       Yet  some  Japan-­‐enthusiasts  will  sometimes  claim  to  know  more  about  Japan   than  me  because  I  have  not  lived  in  Japan  since  I  was  five  years  old.    Worse  yet,   when   I   tell   people   that   I   am   Japanese,   they’ll   respond   with   their   love   for   a   very   specific   commodity   that   encapsulates   the   essence   of   Japan   in   their   minds.     “Oh,   you’re  Japanese?”  they’ll  exclaim.    “I  love  sushi!”    This  kind  of  mindset  suggests  a   tendency  of  many  outsiders  to  generalize  culture,  to  see  nationalities  through  their   interaction   with   a   cultural   symbol   without   fully   understanding   its   complicated   background.     In   the   end,   no   outsider   can   truly   understand   a   culture   with   its   untranslatable  nuances  and  demeanors.    Nor  can  an  outsider  hope  to  truly  possess  it   even  if  he  or  she  attempts  to  transfer  it  in  its  most  authentic  form.    This  does  not   mean   that   I   condemn   any   kind   of   cultural   sharing.     Celebrating   diversity   is   important  because  it  promotes  inclusion  and  discourages  racism  and  ignorance.    But   I  also  posit  that  when  enjoying  a  cultural  object,  it  is  important  to  understand  the   concept  of  authenticity  in  the  context  of  modernity.      The  authenticity  that  so  many   people   strive   for   can   never   be   attained   because   in   the   global   food   network,
  • 6.   6   commodities   lose   what   Walter   Benjamin   would   call   their   cultural   “aura”   (1936).       And  as  I  will  show  in  the  following  chapters,  the  rising  popularity  of  green  tea  in  the   global  food  network  clearly  proves  this.        In   the   next   chapter,   I   illustrate   the   moment   when   green   tea   first   gained   significance  as  an  icon  and  as  a  consumption  object.    As  soon  as  it  was  transported   from   China,   it   became   enmeshed   into   the   cultural   frame   of   nation   work   and   the   development  of  a  national  Japanese  identity.    Through  the  tradition  of  Japanese  tea   ceremonies,   it   became   transferred   from   one   generation   to   the   next   and   attained   timelessness.    However,  in  my  third  chapter,  we  see  the  dilution  of  green  tea  culture   in  modern  Japanese  society.      In  the  age  of  mechanical  production,  consumers  care   more   about   convenience   than   quality   and   tradition.       This   is   only   exacerbated   in   other  countries  as  the  idea  of  authenticity  sustains  false  consciousness.    As  I  reveal   in  my  fourth  chapter,  globalization  paradoxically  provokes  desire  for  authenticity   while  also  making  it  impossible  to  truly  attain  it.    And  in  the  fifth  chapter,  we  can  see   the  consequences  of  mass  production  on  developing  countries.     These  issues  are  important  and  timely  because  with  the  rise  of  globalization,   people   have   also   conceived   the   idea   of   a   global   culture   that   may   result   from   the   homogenization   of   various   cultures.     And   with   the   commodification   of   different   cultural  objects,  this  theory  may  not  be  so  wrong.    In  fact,  as  consumers  forget  the   cultural   context   of   a   commodity,   one   may   even   suggest   that   the   resulting   global   culture  is  acultural.    But  does  this  form  of  globalization  promote  equality?    Or  does  it   only  encourage  racist  appropriations?    This  is  my  thesis.    The  crowning  argument   that  I  illustrate  through  the  globalization  of  green  tea.
  • 7.   7   2.  Sado:  the  Japanese  tradition  of  tea   preparation  as  a  class  culture     Japan’s  national  identity:  the  influence  of  Sado’s  (茶道)  religious   and  aesthetic  philosophy     In  today’s  world,  when  one  investigates  on  matcha,  it  is  always  undeniably   associated  with  the  ancient  tradition  of  Japanese  tea  ceremony.    In  fact,  the  custom,   or   sado-­-­as   the   tea   ceremony   is   called-­-­is   one   of   the   most   popular   forms   of   entertainment  that  the  Japanese  use  to  introduce  foreigners  to  their  cultural  values.     Many   Japanese   political   figures   have   welcomed   foreign   heads   of   state   with   the   traditional  preparation  and  offering  of  tea.    Sado  has  even  been  featured  in  several   World  Expos  throughout  history  (Surak  2013:86).    This  is  because  while  green  tea   originated  in  China,  it  became  the  primary  subject  in  sado,  a  distinctive  ritual  for  the   Japanese  people,  which  helps  define  their  national  identity  through  its  philosophical   and  aesthetic  ideals.     Such  customs  are  important  for  societies  because  a  representative  culture  is   what   binds   individuals   together   and   helps   them   build   a   sense   of   nationalism.     “…Studies   have   shown   how   myths,   symbols,   customs,   memories,   and   beliefs   that   more  or  less  loosely  bind  members  of  an  ethnic  community  together  have  provided   raw  material  for  nationalists  to  work  into  representative  cultures,  which  then  have   been  used  to  establish  the  identity  and  uniqueness  of  the  nation  as  the  legitimate
  • 8.   8   grounds  of  its  political  sovereignty”  (Surak  2013:2).    This  distinction  of  cultivating   an   identity   creates   a   divide   between   “us”   and   “them”   which   makes   “us”   unique.     What   begins   as   a   common   ritual   eventually   develops   into   a   representation,   a   cultural  act  that  expresses  a  common  identity  and  creates  a  sense  of  belonging  in  a   certain  group.           Japan’s  maturation  into  a  nation-­‐state  first  began  when  Commodore  Matthew   C.   Perry   forcefully   opened   Japan   to   foreign   trade   in   1852.     At   the   sight   of   Perry   rolling   into   the   port   with   his   “black   ships”,   symbolizing   Western   superiority   in   technology,  the  urgent  need  to  modernize  took  root  in  Japanese  minds  and  a  cultural   upheaval  took  place  as  people  abandoned  old  customs  for  progress  (Okakura  1964).     Many   threw   away   their   kimonos,   their   swords,   and   traditional   family   lineages   adopting  Western  garb  and  studying  Western  philosophy  instead.    But  amidst  this   transformation,  there  also  developed  a  national  consciousness,  an  inherent  desire  to   battle  against  Westernization  and  preserve  a  sense  of  Japaneseness.       Kristin   Surak   states   that   this   need   to   prove   one’s   Japanese   identity   manifested   itself   in   sado.     In   fact,   this   custom   reached   a   pivotal   moment   in   the   Western  world’s  consciousness  when  Kakuzo  Okakura,  a  Japanese  polymath,  began   a  literary  discourse  in  1906  over  the  significance  of  tea  in  his  work,  The  Book  of  Tea.     While  green  tea  had  always  been  an  important  part  of  Japanese  culture,  Okakura’s   treatise   inspired   other   intellectuals   to   define   a   national   consciousness,   a   national   “we”  based  on  the  practice  by  describing  its  cultural  synthesis  of  traditional  arts  and   national   etiquette.     Such   discourse   helped   establish   sado  as   a   legitimized   custom
  • 9.   9   that   wasn’t   just   a   deed   but   had   cultural   significance   that   could   be   explored   and   described  in  words.    By  calling  this  a  nationalist  act,  it  became  one.       On  the  other  hand,  while  almost  every  Japanese  person  in  today’s  society  has   practiced  the  ritual  at  one  point  in  their  lives,  the  tradition  of  sado  is  remote  from   most  peoples’  daily  existence  because  it  is  accepted  as  a  spiritual  sacred  rite  and   therefore  must  be  inaccessible  to  the  common  man.    It  is  a  practice  that  requires  a   lot  of  training  because  every  symbolic  gesture,  every  tool,  even  the  clothes  of  the   participants   and   the   space   itself   expresses   Zen   Buddhist   ideals   on   reaching   Enlightenment   (J.   Anderson   1991:24).     In   fact,   it   is   for   this   very   objective   of   cultivating  the  mind  for  Enlightenment  that  sado,  or  “the  way  of  tea”  became  the   official  term  for  the  custom.       In  the  end,  this  religious  belief  had  materialized  into  a  tangible  symbol  that   could   be   practiced   and   repeated.    As   Emile   Durkheim   explains   in   The  Elementary   Forms   of   Life,   religion   inherently   requires   expression   of   worship   in   the   form   of   rituals  (1912).    And  in  turn,  when  a  religion  such  as  Zen  Buddhism  becomes  widely   practiced  in  a  nation  for  many  years,  it  becomes  an  art  woven  into  the  very  fabric  of   the   society’s   national   culture.     Regardless   of   whether   they   practice   it   or   not,   this   lasting  custom  has  bound  the  people  under  one  identity  and  has  established  a  way   in   which   they   can   express   their   group’s   ideals.     Even   if   some   of   the   original   motivations   for   tea   preparation   have   become   obscured,   the   space,   objects   and   performance   of   the   Japanese   tea   ceremony   still   upholds   the   values   prevalent   in   Japan’s  national  personality.
  • 10.   10   One   of   these   characteristics   is   the   Japanese   general   tendency   towards   introspection   and   mutual   respect.     In   a   collectivist   society   such   as   Japan’s,   it   is   important   to   belong   to   a   group.     “Group   identity   is   strong   and   there   is   a   definite   sense  of  who  is  inside  and  outside  a  particular  group.”  (J.  Anderson  1991:219)  In   turn,  the  conforming  group  is  often  favored  over  individual  attention.    “There  is  an   emphasis   on   conformity   within   the   group   and   individuals   are   discouraged   from   displaying  expertise  that  is  not  commensurate  with  that  of  the  group  as  a  whole.”  (J.   Anderson  1991:219)  As  a  result,  the  Japanese  have  come  to  value  cleanliness  and  a   seemingly   excessive   mindfulness   of   others   in   their   lives.     However,   instead   of   making  society  more  collaborative  in  nature,  this  has  caused  many  individuals  to   interiorize  many  of  their  own  thoughts.    While  belonging  to  a  group  is  important,   this   self-­‐effacement   of   the   individual   has   also   led   people   to   delve   inwards   and   paradoxically  grow  more  isolated  from  the  group.     This   is   especially   reflected   in   the   slow   and   deliberate   movements   of   each   gesture  in  sado  as  the  person  preparing  the  tea  silently  offers  the  finished  product  to   his   or   her   guest.      There   is   no   dialogue,   no   excessive   movement   as   the   preparer   wipes  the  cup  and  bowing,  presents  it  to  the  receiver.    While  the  initial  purpose  of   the  custom  is  to  demonstrate  respect,  there  is  also  a  distance  between  the  giver  and   the  receiver  caused  by  the  formality  of  this  exchange.  In  the  end,  both  sides  seem  to   be  experiencing  their  relationship  to  the  tea  rather  than  to  each  other.       Meanwhile,  by  celebrating  introspection  and  respect  for  others,  sado  invites   the  participants  to  contemplate  on  the  aesthetic  beauty  and  balance  of  such  a  simple   custom.  According  to  Jennifer  L.  Anderson,  while  many  tea  masters  have  presented
  • 11.   11   varying   interpretations   of   Zen   through   the   different   evolutions   of   sado,   Shuko   Murata   (1422-­‐1502)   developed   an   important   style   of   aesthetic   sensitivity   called   wabi,  which  focused  on  the  simplicity  of  Japanese  tea  ceremonies  (1991:29).    In  fact,   simplicity  is  one  of  the  most  important  characteristics  of  the  Japanese  tea  ritual.    By   emphasizing  the  muted  beauty  of  unadorned  tools,  clothes,  decorations,  and  space,   the   wabi   aesthetic   attempts   to   emphasize   details   and   heighten   contemplative   awareness  of  the  relationship  between  people  and  objects.       Sen   no   Rikyu   (1522-­‐1591),   known   as   the   most   important   tea   master   in   Japanese   history,   builds   on   this   idea   of   simplicity   by   emphasizing   its   sense   of   humility   and   artistic   integrity   (J.   Anderson   1991:34).     This   in   turn   suggests   the   importance   of   experience   rather   than   the   objects   themselves.     “Zen   adepts   theoretically   reject   the   mediation   of   esoteric   symbols,   relying   instead   on   direct   experience.”   (J.   Anderson   1991:55)   For   Rikyu,   the   tools   and   décor   are   merely   cultural  vessels  for  creating  and  transmitting  a  setting,  an  ephemeral  moment  that  is   to  be  enjoyed  by  the  body.             This  correlation  between  sado  rituals  and  collective  personality  depicts  the   custom’s  important  role  in  Japan’s  sense  of  nationalism.    As  Okakura  described  in   The   Book   of   Tea,   not   only   is   the   Japanese   tea   ceremony   a   cultural   symbol   representing  an  identity,  but  also  through  its  practice,  one  is  able  to  express  and   develop  truly  Japanese  values.    “…It  is  not  Japanese  culture  that  generates  tea,  but   tea  that  generates  Japanese  culture.”  (Surak  2013:82)    In  fact,  Okakura  goes  on  to   state  that  “Teaism”  defines  the  very  essence  of  Japanese  life.       The  Philosophy  of  Tea  is  not  mere  aestheticism  in  the  ordinary  acceptance  of  the   term,   for   it   expresses   conjointly   with   ethics   and   religion   our   whole   point   of   view
  • 12.   12   about  man  and  nature.    It  is  hygiene,  for  it  enforces  cleanliness;  it  is  economics,  for  it   shows   comfort   in   simplicity   rather   than   in   the   complex   and   costly;   it   is   moral   geometry,   in   as   much   as   it   defines   our   sense   of   proportion   to   the   universe.     It   represents  the  true  spirit  of  Eastern  democracy  by  making  all  its  votaries  aristocrats   in  taste.”  (Okakura  1964:1)     Through  this  perspective,  one  sees  the  inseparable  relationship  between  sado,  green   tea  itself,  and  the  Japanese  people.    Since  its  introduction  from  China,  green  tea  has   turned  into  a  cultural  symbol  that  reaffirms  Japanese  identity  time  and  time  again.     It’s  significant  past  ensures  its  survival  in  the  future.           In   fact,   in   the   words   of   Benedict   Anderson,   this   kind   of   custom   creates   an   “imagined  community”  which  relies  on  the  cultural  symbol’s  longevity  (2006).    After   all,   Anderson   argues   that   nationalism   by   nature   promises   a   timeless   sense   of   solidarity  with  a  lineage  based  both  in  the  past  and  into  the  future.    There  must  be   an   imagined   sense   of   continuity   and   an   assumption   that   one’s   beliefs   will   be   inherited  and  preserved  by  the  community.    “If  nation-­‐states  are  widely  conceded  to   be  ‘new’  and  ‘historical’,  the  nations  to  which  they  give  political  expression  always   loom   out   of   an   immemorial   past,   and   still   more   important,   glide   into   a   limitless   future.”     (B.   Anderson   2006:11)   However,   as   nations   evolve,   so   do   their   culture.     What  would  happen  if  sado  were  forgotten  in  today’s  society?    Can  it  be  replaced  by   new   cultural   symbols?       Could   Japan   still   retain   the   same   sense   of   nationalism   without  sado?    Such  speculation  will  be  addressed  later  when  green  tea  leaves  the   context  of  the  tea  ceremony.           Gender  Discrimination  and  Social  Stratification  in  Modern   Practices
  • 13.   13   Over   time,   people   have   argued   that   the   tradition   of   tea   preparation   has   continued  to  encourage  social  stratification.    After  all,  since  its  arrival  from  China,   the  preparation  of  green  tea  had  been  primarily  practiced  by  certain  elite  classes   such   as   the   aristocracy   and   wealthy   merchants   as   an   expression   of   hierarchical   distinction  (J.  Anderson  1991).    In  addition,  it  is  important  to  note  that  while  many   people  believe  that  matcha  and  green  tea  can  be  used  interchangeably,  matcha  is  in   fact  a  type  of  green  tea  that  is  more  expensive  and  higher  grade  than  the  average   green   tea   label.     As   a   result,   its   exclusive   use   in   Japanese   tea   ceremonies   also   suggests  an  elite  culture  only  navigable  to  those  with  expendable  wealth.    Today,   many  people  in  the  upper  classes  still  believe  that  sado  is  an  art,  a  cultural  capital   that   should   be   cultivated   for   its   refinement   and   its   prestige   for   the   family   name.     They  attend  expensive  classes  and  buy  the  traditional  kimonos  and  unique  tools  for   tea  preparation.  “Symbolic  capital,  especially  the  prestige  and  honor  of  the  family   name  is  also  a  key  criterion  in  defining  class”  (Chiba  2011:88).       Perhaps  it  is  for  this  reason  that  sado  is  sometimes  considered  a  luxury.    In   an  attempt  to  remain  faithful  to  the  customs,  one  must  have  the  means  to  attain  the   tools  for  the  ritual.    And  the  more  authentic  the  tools  are,  the  more  expensive  and   the   higher   the   acclaim   the   owners   receive   for   their   high   status.     “Practitioners   continually  display  their  objectified  forms  of  cultural  capital  and  use  them  as  tools   to  differentiate  themselves  from  other  practitioners”  (Chiba  2011:79).    In  this  way,   one  can  observe  the  distinctions  of  classes.    Pierre  Bourdieu,  a  French  sociologist   known   for   his   treatise   on   French   culture   in   the   60s,   would   suggest   that   the   ceremony  is  a  form  of  “symbolic  power”  that  preserves  the  social  hierarchy  (Surak
  • 14.   14   2011:176).     By   possessing   cultural   capital,   the   upper   classes   assume   dominance   over  others.       On  the  other  hand,  in  modern  Japan,  this  practice  has  also  been  extended  to   middle-­‐class   non-­‐working   women   who   are   attracted   to   its   promise   of   teaching   proper  etiquette,  manners  and  a  certain  feminine  gracefulness.      Attaining  the  skills   of   tea   preparation   is   desirable   because   it   elevates   those   that   have   been   deemed   qualified  from  the  rest  and  gives  this  person  a  more  respectable  reputation.    “Thus,   in   learning   chado   women   are   taught   all   the   traditional   arts   and   as   a   result,   are   perceived   by   other   Japanese   (who   may   or   may   not   study   chado)   as   intelligent,   cultured,  talented,  and  worthy  of  esteem.”  (Mori  1991:94)  In  this  way,  middle-­‐class   women  can  seemingly  attain  perceived  social  mobility  and  gain  access  to  a  ritual   associated  with  the  higher  class.       But  why  did  sado  spread  to  this  demographic  when  it  used  to  be  primarily   practiced   by   male   Buddhist   monks   and   the   upper   class?     During   the   Tokugawa   period,  sado  was  practiced  among  the  elite  and  it  was  only  considered  as  a  ritual,   which  facilitated  class  distinction.    This  changed  during  the  Meiji  Regime,  after  Japan   opened  its  doors  to  westernization,  when  Japanese  girls’  education  became  one  of   the   systems   through   which   the   government   attempted   to   preserve   its   sense   of   nationalism  (Surak  2013:73).    Suddenly,  sado  became  one  of  the  important  national   rituals  that  would  help  preserve  Japaneseness.       Featuring  different  sado  etiquettes  in  public  school  textbooks,  the  Japanese   government   specifically   focused   on   girls   because   Minister   Kabayama   Sukenori   believed   that   as   future   house   makers,   women   were   responsible   for   building   the
  • 15.   15   foundations  of  the  nation,  and  therefore  it  was  their  duty  to  “nourish  a  warm  and   chaste   character   and   the   most   beautiful   and   elevated   temperament”   (Surak   2013:74).     On   the   other   hand,   the   tea   ceremony   only   appeared   briefly   in   boys’   textbooks   as   a   recreational   hobby.     This   was   because   with   the   rise   of   industrial   society,   all   men   were   expected   to   work.     They   no   longer   had   time   for   aesthetic   pursuits.    Thus  began  the  nationalization  of  sado  as  a  feminine  culture  and  its  rise  as   an  integrated  part  of  Japanese  identity.    “The  tea  ceremony  was  not  simply  a  flat   symbol,   but   a   lived   practice,   with   bodies   conveying   its   national   dissemination”   (Surak  2013:171).     Some  have  argued  that  this  has  led  to  women  empowerment  because  while   the   practice   of   ritual   does   not   enable   Japanese   women   to   acquire   economic   or   political   power,   it   gives   them   an   opportunity   to   influence   and   participate   in   the   transmission  of  Japanese  culture.  “Although  seemingly  only  a  means  for  subjugating   and  training  women  for  subordinate  roles,  chado  is  also  a  provider  of  a  place  where   women  are  in  control  of  their  lives.”  (Mori  1991:86)  For  example,  in  Kaeko  Chiba’s   ethnographic  interviews  with  women  practicing  sado,  many  women  affirmed  that   practicing   the   custom   empowered   them   because   while   many   of   them   had   less   education   than   their   husbands,   they   felt   more   cultured   (Chiba   2011:112).     They   believed  that  by  learning  the  art  of  an  important  national  heritage,  they  were  closing   the  education  gap  between  them  and  their  male  counterparts.   On   the   other   hand,   despite   the   fact   that   the   tradition   is   predominantly   practiced  by  women,  the  iemoto  or  family  foundation  which  has  appropriated  the   entire  culture  of  sado  in  Japan,  is  completely  headed  by  men  (Mori  1991:87).    They
  • 16.   16   are  the  ones  who  give  permission  for  tea  ceremonies  to  be  taught.    They  are  the   ones  who  authorize  every  tea  preparation  tool  to  be  used.    Their  control  over  the   diffusion  and  preservation  of  sado  is  strict.    “Within  the  structure  of  the  Urasenke   iemoto  system,  women  still  hold  lower  positions,  and  their  ability  to  devote  all  of   their  energies  to  chado  is  doubted,  as  the  roles  of  wife  and  mother  are  expected  to   compete  with  dedication  to  the  art.”  (Mori  1991:96)    While  women  are  allowed  to   become  instructors,  they  cannot  hold  high  positions  in  this  controlled  family  legacy.       Such   traditions   have   not   been   contested   because   many   accept   that   it   has   always   been   the   custom   and   to   change   the   structure,   would   be   to   taint   its   authenticity.    It  is  the  same  reason  that  men  are  the  only  ones  allowed  to  play  the   customary  instruments  in  traditional  matsuri  festivals,  that  women  are  not  allowed   to  step  foot  on  the  floats  made  for  the  parades.    While  Japanese  men  are  allowed  to   roam  freely  between  cultural  practices  and  the  labor  force,  women  generally  seem   to  be  designated  to  lower  positions  in  both  aspects  and  once  they  are  married,  their   prospects  are  narrowed  even  further.    In  the  end,  if  women’s  choices  after  marriage   are  to  either  be  a  house  maker  or  to  be  a  “cultured”  house  maker,  it  is  evident  that   the  current  tradition  of  sado  does  not  reduce  gender  inequalities.         This  division  between  feminine  and  masculine  activities  can  also  be  observed   in  the  rest  of  society.    As  rising  Japanese  feminists  demanding  gender  equality  have   started  to  hold  influence,  Japanese  society  has  slowly  begun  to  evolve  in  both  the   labor  force  and  in  education.    More  women  now  have  attained  higher  education  and   work   despite   the   fact   that   they   still   cannot   hold   higher   positions   in   companies   (“Holding   back”   2014).     However,   this   idea   of   equality   differs   from   American
  • 17.   17   feminism   in   that   Japanese   women   still   strive   to   retain   their   “feminineness”   by   separating  themselves  from  men.       For  example,  in  subway  cars,  the  American  idea  of  equality  would  be  for  men   and   women   to   sit   side   by   side   without   any   discrimination.     However,   women   in   Japan   have   demanded   distinction   by   claiming   that   they   had   a   right   to   reserve   “women  only”  seats  to  protect  themselves  from  sexual  harassment.    Such  positive   discrimination   is   perhaps   the   reason   why   sado   is   considered   a   tool   for   female   empowerment.    By  claiming  the  culture  as  their  own,  many  middle  and  upper  class   women  have  attempted  to  elevate  the  social  positions  of  women  in  respect  to  their   male  counterparts.    “Although  Japanese  society  is  still  a  world  divide  between  men   and  women,  with  men  predominantly  active  in  the  public  sphere,  women  have  used   to  [their]  advantage  the  places  open  to  them,  such  as  chado,  where  they  are  able  to   pursue  individual  goals;  exercise  limited  control  and  choice;  gain  skills  training,  and   self-­‐confidence;  and  somewhat  influence  the  course  of  their  lives  and  the  lives  of   those  with  whom  they  come  into  contact.”  (Mori  1991:96)       In  the  end,  when  analyzing  the  way  Japan  has  addressed  its  gender  gap,  it  is   important   to   consider   the   cultural   factors   which   have   shaped   the   Japanese   conception  of  equality.    Their  values  are  different  from  those  of  the  West  in  that  the   traditional   roles   are   still   widely   accepted   today.       To   belittle   these   values   is   to   disregard  the  complicated  fabric  of  a  nation’s  history  in  favor  of  Western  ideology.   And   it   is   perhaps   for   this   reason   that   both   Chiba   and   Mori   have   adopted   more   conservative   views   on   women   empowerment   in   their   ethnographic   studies   by   focusing   on   the   women’s   individual   sense   of   fulfillment.     From   an   outsider’s
  • 18.   18   perspective,  many  would  not  view  women’s  involvement  in  sado  as  a  sufficient  step   towards  achieving  gender  equality  because  despite  their  majority  in  the  field,  they   still  cannot  hold  the  highest  positions  in  the  institution  due  to  antiquated  traditions   of  family  inheritance.    However,  the  practice  of  this  ritual  has  also  helped  generate  a   sense  of  female  solidarity  which  should  not  be  overlooked.       As   expected,   this   desire   to   practice   a   culture   is   not   salient   among   every   Japanese   person.     In   today’s   modern   era,   less   people   have   been   exposed   to   the   tradition,   especially   in   progressive   metropolitan   cities   such   as   Tokyo.     Some   Japanese   people   view   the   custom   as   “too   strict”,   “too   exclusionary”,   or   “too   pretentious”   because   of   its   association   with   the   upper   classes   and   its   rigidity   in   terms  of  manners  (J.  Anderson  1991:222).    With  the  deterioration  of  keigo,  or  polite   language   with   every   new   generation,   one   also   observes   the   breakdown   of   social   values.     In   an   effort   to   maintain   its   position   in   global   competition,   Japan   has   continued  to  slowly  evolve  thus  neglecting  to  sufficiently  teach  the  new  generation   its  cultural  heritage.    Despite  Kyoto’s  attempts  to  preserve  the  authenticity  of  sado   and  its  mainstream  presence  through  the  media,  the  traditional  values  and  detailed   practice  has  become  more  and  more  obscured  due  to  Western  influence.       Yet   when   one   asks   about   matcha   today,   Japanese   people   still   proudly   associate   it   to   their   national   identity   and   it   continues   to   remain   in   the   media   because   sado’s   “…cultural   synthesis   of   national   architecture,   ceramics,   cuisine,   costume,   and   other   arts…”   has   become   so   enmeshed   in   national   culture   by   the   institution   of   iemoto   (Surak   2013:186).     Sado’s   value   as   a   symbolic   capital   has   continued  to  sustain  the  importance  of  green  tea  as  a  symbol  itself.    In  fact,  unlike
  • 19.   19   Japanese   incense,   which   now   occupies   a   more   reclusive   section   of   culture   in   people’s   minds,   sado  has   established   itself   as   one   of   the   most   important   national   rituals  to  preserve  because  of  the  evolution  of  green  tea.    “As  extraordinary  versions   of   the   ordinary,   the   spaces,   objects   and   gestures   of   which   the   ritual   is   composed   offer  a  shifting  balance  between  the  exotic  and  the  mundane  that  has  preserved  its   aura   in   the   fraught   move   from   nation-­‐building   to   nation-­‐maintenance”   (Surak   2013:186).         But   as   green   tea   continues   to   grow   as   a   global   commodity,   its   association  with  Japanese  identity  may  become  more  and  more  questionable.         Japanese  Green  Tea  vs.  Chinese  Green  Tea   While   green   tea   has   always   been   associated   with   its   cultural   ties   to   Japan,   today’s  market  shows  that  Japan  in  fact  exports  less  than  two  percent  of  the  green   tea  in  the  world  market.       (Source:  Groosman  2011:6)
  • 20.   20   So  why  do  many  consumers  associate  green  tea  with  Japanese  culture  more  than   Chinese   culture?     For   one,   the   Japanese   tea   ritual   is   more   well-­‐known   than   its   Chinese  predecessor,  Cha’an.    Since  Eichu,  a  Japanese  monk,  brought  green  tea  from   China  in  A.D.  804,  the  Japanese  had  continued  to  further  develop  the  Chinese  tea   preparation   ritual   so   that   it   became   one   synthesized   art   under   the   banner   of   nationalism  (J.  Anderson  1991).      “Tea  with  us  became  more  than  an  idealization  of   the  form  of  drinking;  it  is  a  religion  of  the  art  of  life.”  (Okakura  1964:17)         In   effect,   Jennifer   Anderson   argues   that   while   the   Chinese   tea   ritual   continued   to   serve   a   united   purpose   of   expressing   religious   philosophies,   it   was   Japan  that  truly  integrated  it  into  its  cultural  fabric.    “But,  even  though  the  process  of   synthesizing   Confucian,   Taoist,   and   Buddhist   cognitive   systems   through   tea   ritual   had  begun,  [Chinese]  practitioners  had  yet  to  address  the  problem  of  salvation  or   use   tea   ritual   as   an   effective   vehicle   for   transforming   their   outlook   on   life.”   (J.   Anderson  1991:22)  For  the  Japanese,  tea  was  not  just  another  ritual;  it  also  helped   define   their   entire   lifestyle.     Therefore,   as   Okakura’s   The   Book   of   Tea   illustrates,   whenever  they  began  to  lose  a  sense  of  national  identity,  they  always  looked  to  tea   to   remind   themselves   and   others   of   their   Japaneseness   (1964).     When   the   West   began  to  expand  its  reach  in  Japan,  green  tea  and  the  ritual  of  preparing  it  helped   preserve   a   sense   of   solidarity.     In   other   words,   one   can   attribute   green   tea’s   prominence  in  the  global  consciousness  to  Japan’s  constant  reaffirmations  of  their   nationalism.       Nevertheless,  it  is  important  to  not  overlook  the  origin  of  sado  and  green  tea   in   China.       The   Japanese   cannot   deny   that   their   cultural   foundation   was   heavily
  • 21.   21   influenced   by   Chinese   culture   and   philosophy.       Through   travel   to   China,   many   Japanese   intellectuals   transported   knowledge   and   physical   objects   back   to   their   home   where   they   were   adopted   and   reshaped   to   fit   their   values.     “Instead   of   conquering   armies,   merchants   and   traveling   monks   -­‐   and   eventually   Japanese   students  who  studied  in  China  -­‐  were  the  most  important  agents  by  which  elements   of  Chinese  culture  were  transmitted.”  (Stearns  2000)       Interestingly   enough,   this   transportation   was   viewed   as   a   threat   to   the   preservation  of  Japanese  culture.      Instead  of  adopting  the  perspective  of  Japanese   appropriating   Chinese   ideals,   many   scholars   see   Chinese   influence   on   the   rest   of   Asia   as   an   oppressive   force   which   the   Japanese   thwarted   through   political   independence.    “Because  the  Japanese  remained  politically  independent  from  China,   their   rulers   could   convincingly   argue   that   the   adoption   of   Chinese   ways   was   voluntary   and   carefully   controlled.”   (Stearns   2000)     In   turn,   the   transmission   of   knowledge   was   called   “selective   borrowing”,   which   further   suggests   that   the   transportation  of  the  tea  and  its  ritual  were  not  a  form  of  appropriation  (Stearns   2000).    This  is  because  “appropriation”  proposes  the  idea  that  China  was  somehow   marginalized  in  this  process,  which  was  not  the  case.   “…In   the   early   days   of   tea   history,   the   Japanese   were   intrigued   by   the   splendid   products  of  Chinese  civilization  but  also  vaguely  threatened  by  the  potential  loss  of   cultural  identity  their  adoption  represented.    The  Japanese  responded  by  integrating   attractive   features   of   the   resultant   synthesis   as   their   own.     They   did   this   so   successfully  that  one  such  amalgamation,  tea  ritual,  became  a  symbol  of  ‘Japanese’   culture  recognized  all  over  the  world.”  (J.  Anderson  1991:224)     Meanwhile,  if  one  were  to  ask  the  average  consumer  to  compare  and  contrast   Japanese  green  tea  from  Chinese  green  tea,  most  people  would  not  know  how  to   proceed.    In  fact,  the  amateur  observer  would  probably  not  even  realize  that  there  is
  • 22.   22   a  difference.    However,  China’s  green  tea  omits  a  significant  step  in  the  processing   system  which  prevents  oxidization.    Because  Japan’s  processors  steam  the  tea  rather   than  firing  it  in  a  pan  like  China,  its  green  tea  remains  fresher  for  longer,  giving  it  a   grassier  more  bitter  taste  (Becki  2013).    In  addition,  this  system  gives  Chinese  green   tea   a   more   yellowish   hue   compared   to   Japanese   tea’s   vibrant   green   color.     Nevertheless,  many  consumers  remain  indifferent  to  the  distinctions,  assuming  that   green  tea  is  the  same  regardless  of  its  origin.
  • 23.   23   3.  Bottled  Tea,  Instant  Tea:  the  fast  food   movement  and  its  consequences     Mechanical  Production:  Accessibility  and  the  Disintegration  of   Culture     In   Japan,   it   is   almost   impossible   to   walk   the   streets   in   a   city   without   encountering   at   least   one   vending   machine.     In   fact,   vending   machines   selling   bottled  drinks  and  cigarettes  are  so  prolific,  that  it  almost  blends  into  the  landscape.     According   to   the   Japan   National   Tourism   Organization,   there   are   currently   5.52   million  vending  machines  nationwide  that  accumulate  annual  sales  of  almost  6.95   trillion   yen.     Not   only   do   these   machines   sell   drinks   and   cigarettes,   but   they   also   those  which  sell  candy  and  ice  cream,  magazines,  emergency  towels  and  underwear,   flowers,  instant  noodles,  the  list  goes  on  and  on.         Since   the   first   vending   machine   was   introduced   in   1888   selling   cigarettes,   numbers  have  grown  so  that  Japan  now  holds  the  record  for  most  vending  machines   in  ratio  to  the  country’s  total  land  area  (JNTO).      But  why  Japan?        According  to   Robert   Parry,   this   popularity   can   be   attributed   to   Japan’s   considerably   low   crime   rate,  high  land  prices,  and  high  labor  costs  (Parry  1998:124).    Not  only  do  vending   machines   rarely   get   vandalized,   but   because   vending   machines   produce   more   revenue  per  square  meter  of  land  than  a  retail  store,  they  are  more  profitable.    This
  • 24.   24   form   of   mechanical   mass   production   allows   beverage   corporations   to   accurately   calculate  sales  without  having  to  account  for  human  errors.      Thus  the  distribution   method  is  advantageous  precisely  because  it  is  more  calculable.         Meanwhile,   vending   machines   offer   easier   accessibility   with   less   hassle   of   dealing  with  a  store  clerk.      As  new  adaptations  emerge  inabling  greater  dispersion,   consumers  gain  more  and  more  incentive  to  purchase  these  fast  and  easy  products.         Canned  coffee,  a  product  unique  to  Japan,  provides  a  good  example.    Sales  of  cold   drinks,  the  mainstay  of  vending  machines  in  Japan’s  sweltering  summer  heat,  not   surprisingly  sag  in  winter.    However  in  1969,  the  UCC  company  produced  coffee  in  a   can  that  could  be  sold  either  hot  or  cold.    This  technological  breakthrough  freed  the   coffee  machines  from  the  need  for  water  supply.    The  idea  quickly  caught  on  with   the   public,   as   well   as   with   UCC’s   competitors.     The   innovation   helped   triple   the   number   of   machines   in   five   years,   with   a   sixfold   increase   in   fifteen   years”   (Parry   1998:125)     This  example  of  the  canned  coffee  innovation  demonstrates  the  Japanese  beverage   corporations’  investment  on  pre-­‐prepared  drinks  while  also  exhibiting  their  ability   to   control   the   production   and   distribution   of   their   commodity.     What’s   more,   by   skipping   the   whole   process   of   having   a   barista   brew   the   coffee   in   front   of   the   customer,  the  customers  can  now  significantly  reduce  their  waiting  time  to  however   long  it  takes  for  the  drink  to  be  dispensed  from  the  shelf,  and  then  enjoy  it  on  the  go.     Talk  about  control  and  efficiency.       Moreover,  another  advantage  to  vending  machines  is  their  reliability.    Since   many  of  the  drinks  have  recognizable  brands  and  uniform  prices,  the  customers  can   always   expect   to   get   exactly   what   they   want.     Everything   is   predictable   and   as   a   result,  everything  is  also  simplified.    “[Predictability]  involves  an  emphasis  on,  for   example,  discipline,  systematization,  and  routine  so  that  things  are  the  same  from   one  time  or  place  to  another.”  (Ritzer  2004:105)    However,  in  a  system  where  the
  • 25.   25   mode   of   production   is   completely   prescribed,   there   is   no   room   for   innovation   or   uniqueness.    Every  time  one  buys  a  regular  coke  in  the  U.S.,  one  always  expects  the   same   taste,   a   reproduction   of   the   same   experience.     “In   the   process,   the   human   craving   for   new   and   diverse   experiences   is   being   limited,   if   not   progressively   destroyed.    It  is  being  supplanted  by  the  desire  for  uniformity  and  predictability.”   (Ritzer  2004:147)   In  the  end,  all  of  these  characteristics  contribute  to  the  phenomenon  called   the  McDonaldization  of  society,  coined  by  sociologist  George  Ritzer.    As  consumers   continue   to   seek   efficiency,   production   will   become   increasingly   rationalized,   de-­‐ skilled,   and   dehumanized   (Ritzer   2004:27).     Not   only   will   the   workers   become   increasingly  alienated  from  the  production  process,  but  consumers  will  also  become   more  alienated  from  their  purchased  product.    What  was  used  to  prepare  the  drink   in  these  pre-­‐packaged  bottles?    How  were  they  made?    What  are  its  true  contents?     Despite  all  of  these  concerning  questions,  the  public  has  seemingly  been  willing  to   surrender   the   quality   and   knowledge   over   what   they   consume   in   exchange   for   efficiency  and  reliability.       As  a  result,  Japanese  culture  is  becoming  diluted.    Because  of  Japan’s  constant   desire   for   progress,   many   of   the   old   traditions   are   forgotten   and   society   now   sustains  a  culture  that  predominantly  revolves  around  consumerism.    In  fact,  even   green   tea   has   been   commodified   by   the   bottled   beverage   industry.       In   2011,   according   to   a   study   conducted   by   the   Ministry   of   Internal   Affairs   and   Communications,   46   percent   of   Japan’s   entire   tea   market   consisted   of   sales   for   bottled  tea  (Akiyama  and  Aoyama  2013).  Initially,  green  tea  was  not  very  popular  in
  • 26.   26   canned   and   bottled   forms   because   it   has   always   been   served   complimentary   in   many  Japanese  restaurants  and  consumers  did  not  want  to  pay  for  something  that   they  usually  receive  for  free.    In  addition,  many  bottled  drinks  could  not  prevent   oxidation  when  the  drinks  were  hot,  which  considerably  shortened  its  shelf  life.       However,  Ito  En  Ltd.,  the  leading  Japanese  beverage  manufacturer  for  ready-­‐ to-­‐drink  green  tea,  saw  a  money-­‐making  opportunity  in  tea  so  that  in  addition  to   adding  Vitamin  C  which  slows  down  oxidation,  designed  a  five-­‐layer  bottle  which   contains   an   oxygen-­‐absorbing   nylon   sheet   between   the   layers   (Akiyama   and   Aoyama   2013).   With   this   innovation   in   tow,   under   the   vanguard   of   the   Oi   Ocha   brand,  Ito  En  took  green  tea  to  the  market  in  1996  and  was  met  with  much  success.     In  the  graph  below,  one  can  observe  the  rising  sales  of  Ito  En’s  canned  and  bottled   green  tea  beverage  ratio  which  has  continued  to  rise  and  make  up  over  20%  of  all   green  tea  consumption  in  Japan  (Ito  En,  Ltd.)
  • 27.   27   What’s  more,  “Market  researcher  Inryou  Souken  reported  that  the  best-­‐selling  drink   in   plastic   bottles   was   green   tea,   which   racked   up   annual   sales   of   5.1   billion   500-­‐ mililiter  units,  while  black  tea  and  oolong  tea  moved  2.8  billion  and  1.7  billion  units   respectively.”  (Akiyama  and  Aoyama  2013)   Meanwhile,   corporations   such   as   Coca   Cola   Japan   know   that   despite   the   consumers’   alienation   from   the   production   of   tea,   the   bottled   tea   industry   would   become  even  more  profitable  if  they  seemingly  maintained  its  quality  (Akiyama  and   Aoyama  2013).    After  all,  from  the  consumers’  perspective,  the  ideal  product  would   be   both   efficient   and   high   grade.     As   a   result,   Coca   Cola   Japan   has   worked   on   enhancing  their  tea’s  nigori,  or  turbidity,  which  is  often  considered  to  create  a  richer   taste   and   is   associated   with   higher   caliber   tea.     By   partnering   with   Kanbayashi   Shunsho  Honten,  a  Kyoto-­‐based  manufacturer  that  has  been  running  for  450  years,   Coca   Cola   introduced   its   Ayataka   brand   tea   made   with   fine   green   tea   powder   in   2007  (Akiyama  and  Aoyama  2013).      Because  of  its  success,  many  other  companies   have  also  joined  the  bandwagon  so  that  these  ready-­‐made  beverages  still  manage  to   retain  some  sense  of  quality.       In  this  age  of  mass  mechanical  production,  it  is  interesting  to  consider  the   manipulations  large  corporations  have  made  in  order  to  increase  sales.    The  taste   that   used   to   be   produced   naturally   through   cultural   practices   has   now   been   reproduced  and  perfected  to  a  science  by  highly  bureaucratized  large  corporations.     However,  even  this  does  not  account  for  the  variability,  the  unique  experiences  one   attains  from  preparing  one’s  own  tea.    Regardless,  this  resemblance  of  quality  and   authenticity   has   helped   convince   many   to   purchase   what   already   promises   both
  • 28.   28   efficiency   and   security.       But   as   soon   as   green   tea   entered   the   system   of   mass   production,   it   had   become   just   another   commodity,   simply   a   green   leaf   removed   from  its  cultural  context.    One  could  put  a  label,  an  image  of  a  traditional  woman  in   the  middle  of  a  sado  ritual  on  the  advertisement,  but  the  rationalization  of  green  tea   has   rendered   it   superficial.     Therefore,   by   extension,   one   can   suggest   that   the   consumerist   culture   facilitated   by   neoliberal   capitalism   has   inevitably   diluted   traditional  nationalist  culture.
  • 29.   29   4.  Raising  cultural  consciousness?  Entrance   into  the  global  food  network       Physical  modes  of  entry   Cafés:  selling  the  experience     Even  before  Starbucks  capitalized  the  concept,  cafés  have  been  the  principal   establishments   for   the   many   consumers   in   search   of   a   prepared   beverage   and   a   place   of   repose.     According   to   Ray   Oldenburg,   an   urban   sociologist   from   the   80s,   cafés  are  popular  because  people  often  search  for  a  “third  space”  where  they  can   escape  from  the  social  roles  that  being  at  home  (the  first  space)  and  being  at  work   (the   second   space)   require   (2013).     With   their   leisurely   atmospheres   and   their   sense  of  public  anonymity,  cafés  allow  the  consumers  to  catch  a  break,  to  connect   with  the  community  and  friends,  and  sometimes  even  start  cultural  revolutions  all   while  enjoying  a  cup  of  coffee  or  tea.         However,  while  small  cafés  continue  to  stay  in  business,  large  corporations   such   as   Starbucks,   the   Coffee   Bean,   and   Peet’s   Coffee   and   Tea   have   established   themselves   at   the   forefront   of   the   café   industry   and   continue   to   carry   the   most   influence   on   the   global   market.     This   is   because   with   their   world-­‐renowned   international   brand   strategy,   these   corporations   have   been   able   to   expand   their   branches  to  many  corners  of  the  world.    As  of  March  2014,  Starbucks,  the  leading
  • 30.   30   corporation   in   this   race,   has   more   than   20,000   stores   in   65   countries   (Starbucks   2015).         While  the  café  space  is  an  important  attraction  to  consumers,  the  choices  for   drinks   are   also   attractive   as   every   menu   boasts   different   coffee   beans   and   teas   imported  from  exotic  countries.      In  fact,  stores  seem  to  place  great  emphasis  on  the   fact  that  many  of  the  ingredients  used  to  make  these  beverages  have  been  imported.     For  example,  the  Coffee  Bean  proclaims  that  its  chocolate  is  from  Denmark  and  the   coffee  itself  is  produced  in  Colombia  (Coffee  Bean  2015).    This  kind  of  promotion  is   popular   because   consumers   seek   authenticity.     They   often   assume   that   the   authenticity  of  a  product  will  also  guarantee  its  quality.           One  of  the  most  prominent  international  appearances  of  green  tea  was  when   it  entered  the  Starbucks  menu  in  the  form  of  a  green  tea  latte.    Suddenly,  matcha,   which  had  originally  been  served  in  traditional  sado  settings,  was  now  a  mainstream   flavor.    And  while  its  popularity  had  been  growing  throughout  Asian  countries  in  the   form  of  green  tea  ice  cream,  chocolates,  and  other  fun  foods,  the  powder  had  now   entered   the   western   world,   thanks   to   the   far-­‐reaching   influence   of   coffeehouse   chains  such  as  Starbucks.     In  visiting  Starbucks’s  online  menu,  the  page  dedicated  to  the  green  tea  latte   mentions   sado.     “The   Japanese   tea   ceremony   emphasizes   the   virtues   of   humility,   restraint  and  simplicity,  its  practice  governed  by  a  set  of  highly  ritualized  actions.   But  this  smooth  and  creamy  matcha-­‐based  beverage  can  be  enjoyed  any  way  you   like.  So  by  all  means,  slurp  away  if  you  want  to.”  (Starbucks  2015)  Starbucks  makes   this  reference  to  Japanese  culture  in  order  to  make  the  consumers  believe  that  the
  • 31.   31   green  tea  in  this  latte  is  an  authentic  ingredient  comparable  to  the  high  quality  of   green  tea  used  in  Japanese  tea  ceremonies.      By  making  consumers  presume  that   Starbucks’s  green  tea  is  authentic,  they  attempt  to  appeal  to  the  consumers’  desire   for  authenticity,  while  also  allowing  the  consumer  to  disregard  sado’s  customs.       In   fact,   Starbucks’s   very   foundation   is   based   on   the   idea   of   imitating   “the   Italian  coffeeshop”  and  they  have  built  a  language  around  their  store  transforming   employees  into  baristas  and  cup  size  options  to  tall,  grande,  and  vente.    “[Customers]   want  things  that  are  locally  made  and  closer  to  nature  or  to  their  original  source,   and   as   untainted   as   possible   by   commerce   and   the   naked   ambition   to   get   rich”   (Simon   2009:26).     Starbucks   knew   this   desire   for   more   authentic   and   personal   experiences   and   thus   began   its   enterprise   as   a   sincere   attempt   to   expose   North   Americans  to  the  European  coffee  experience.       For  example,  for  most  of  its  early  developing  years,  Starbucks  followed  the   traditional   methods   for   preparing   its   drinks.     “In   those   days,   Starbucks   used   semiautomatic  Marzoco  machines,  meaning  that  employees  needed  to  know  how  to   make   the   drinks”   (Simon   2009:39).     What’s   more,   Howard   Schultz,   one   of   the   corporation’s  founders,  used  to  proudly  report  that  Starbucks  didn’t  advertise.    Until   2007,   Schultz   never   ran   commercials   or   radio   promos   to   advertise   his   brand   because   he   was   aware   of   the   public   backlash   against   cheap   ploys   that   other   corporations   like   McDonalds   and   Dunkin’   Donuts   used   to   manipulate   consumers   (Simon  2009:40).    And  while  this  did  not  keep  him  from  finding  subtler  means  to   broadcast  the  Starbucks  image,  the  strategy  gave  off  the  sense  that  the  corporation   was  connected  to  customers  on  a  more  intimate  level.
  • 32.   32   Meanwhile,  Schultz  also  decorated  the  interior  of  the  coffeehouses  in  natural   hues   and   packaged   products   in   brown   paper   to   give   them   a   more   local   feel.     By   selling  pastries  that  weren’t  all  perfectly  shaped,  the  company  tried  to  distance  the   image   of   mass-­‐producing   factories   from   consumers’   minds.     “At   first   not   many   people  knew  just  what  a  scone  was,  but  with  its  awkward  shape  and  fruit  filling,  it   looked  at  a  glance  to  be  healthier  and  more  natural  than  an  Egg  McMuffin”  (Simon   2009:41).      Such  counterculture  tactics  illustrated  an  image  of  rebellion  against  the   traditional  conception  of  large  corporations  which  in  turn  helped  develop  a  closer   bond  with  consumers  based  on  trust  and  familiarity.        However,   when   Starbucks   went   mainstream   in   1992,   the   quality   of   the   beverages   declined   as   the   business   expanded   and   generated   more   demand.     Not   only  did  Starbucks  begin  to  roast  its  beans  in  large  factories,  but  it  also  had  them   pre-­‐ground.    Giving  into  the  demand  for  efficiency  at  the  beginning  of  the  twenty-­‐ first  century,  the  company  replaced  its  Marzocco  machines  with  Verismo  machines   which  now  only  required  knowing  how  to  push  a  button  (Simon  2009:46).    “Really,   each  and  every  Starbucks  these  days  operates  like  a  mini-­‐assembly  line…It’s  hard  to   be   authentic   when   you   make   products   with   the   steely   efficiency   of   a   McDonald’s   franchise  or  a  Toyota  plant”  (Simon  2009:47).     In   addition,   Starbucks   receded   further   from   its   original   mission   for   authenticity  when  it  began  introducing  blended  drinks.    While  many  people  like  the   taste  of  pure  coffee,  there  is  also  a  sizeable  portion  of  the  population  that  does  not.     And   in   order   to   appeal   to   this   other   population,   Starbucks   began   to   adopt   mixed   beverages  that  dilute  the  coffee  with  milk  and  sugar.      The  green  tea  latte  has  also
  • 33.   33   faced   the   same   fate.     While   it   still   retains   a   very   faint   bitterness,   it   is   almost   completely  overpowered  by  the  sweet  taste  of  sugar  and  milk.    The  dilution  of  these   commodities   demonstrates   America’s   general   tendency   to   prefer   sweeter   flavors.   This  also  benefits  large  companies  because  the  overpowering  sweetness  can  mask   the  declining  quality  of  the  coffee  or  tea.  Through  the  literal  dilution  of  taste,  one  can   even  suggest  a  disregard  for  the  authentic  taste  that  the  commodities’  countries  of   origin   have   valued.     By   altering   the   taste,   milk   and   sugar   have   become   tools   in   facilitating  indifference  towards  a  commodity’s  authenticity.    And  by  extension,  they   have  helped  large  Western  corporations  dominate  and  appropriate  a  new  standard   for  coffee  and  green  tea.           Needless   to   say,   despite   their   efforts   to   prove   otherwise,   mass   production   has  deteriorated  the  quality  and  authenticity  of  coffee  and  other  ingredients  at  chain   coffeehouses.    So  why  are  consumers  still  inclined  to  go  to  Starbucks  or  the  Coffee   Bean?    According  to  Bryant  Simon,  not  only  do  these  coffeehouses  provide  a  reliable   gathering   third   space,   convenience,   and   familiarity   but   they   also   offer   a   form   of   individual   expression   in   terms   of   status   and   identity   making   because   of   its   emergence   as   an   “affordable   luxury”   (Simon   2009:7).     “It   became   a   cultural   shorthand,   a   way   to   read,   and   be   read   by,   others.”   (Simon   2009:7)     As   a   result,   people  continued  to  purchase  the  different  beverages  with  the  green  mermaid  logo,   advertising  their  belonging  to  a  specific  projected  group  of  seemingly  successful,  hip,   people.    Buying  had  become  a  form  of  self-­‐expression,  and  a  way  to  gain  a  sense  of   belonging  into  the  ideal  social  group.    It  had  become  a  tool  for  class  distinction.    And
  • 34.   34   the   more   people   continued   to   consume   the   Starbucks   experience,   the   more   exposure  and  popularity  green  tea  lattes  gained  as  a  part  of  the  company’s  menu.         Meanwhile,   behind   the   scenes   staged   by   such   large   corporations,   independent  coffee  shops  have  also  attempted  to  introduce  more  green  tea  to  their   menus.     While   they   distinguish   themselves   from   bigger   businesses   by   offering   higher  quality  beverages,  many  of  the  cafés  emulate  the  same  dilution  of  culture  as   Starbucks.     None   of   these   businesses   prepare   matcha   in   the   traditional   way   with   specialized  tools  used  in  a  sado  setting.    Like  Starbucks,  they  may  preserve  the  term   matcha  under  the  guise  of  authenticity,  but  many  of  these  green  tea  drinks  are  often   blended  with  milk  and  sugar  to  weaken  the  bitter  taste  that  is  often  undesirable  for   western   taste.     Even   Asian   boba   houses   discard   the   traditional   for   “modern”   sweetness  as  they  advertise  green  tea  boba  milkshakes.    One  of  these  exceptions  is   the  recent  opening  of  the  MatchaBar  in  Brooklyn,  New  York.     Founded  by  New  York  natives  Max  and  Graham  Fortgang  in  the  fall  of  2014,   this  new  business  has  been  endeavoring  to  preserve  matcha  preparation  in  its  most   close-­‐to-­‐authentic   form   while   also   introducing   it   to   the   modern   café   setting.     Not   only  do  they  prepare  their  tea  with  the  traditional  whisk  at  their  location,  but  they   also  offer  classes  encouraging  customers  to  learn  the  proper  methods.    Establishing   their  own  brand  sourced  directly  from  an  independent  family  farm  in  Nishio,  Japan,   these  entrepreneurs  hope  to  “uplift  and  motivate”  their  community  “with  the  power   of  matcha”  in  its  most  high-­‐quality  and  authentic  form  (MatchaBar  2014).       In   this   new   age   when   start-­‐ups   are   becoming   more   common   and   counterculture  is  the  new  trend,  it  may  be  possible  that  this  new  introduction  to  real
  • 35.   35   cultural  capital  may  take  flight  and  inspire  more  cultural  exposure.    However,  in  this   scenario,  the  question  of  cultural  appropriation  comes  to  light.    Can  one  truly  own   culture?    And  what  constitutes  the  boundaries  where  this  becomes  an  act  of  racism?     Perhaps   in   order   to   determine   whether   MatchaBar   is   a   form   of   cultural   appropriation,   one   must   first   understand   the   difference   between   exchange   and   appropriation.       According   to   Jarune   Uwujaren,   cultural   appropriation   occurs   when   the   dominant   Western   culture   attempts   to   possess   a   marginalized   culture   without   respecting  its  origins  while  also  trying  to  impose  its  own  dominant  culture.    “One  of   the  reasons  that  cultural  appropriation  is  a  hard  concept  to  grasp  for  so  many  is  that   Westerners  are  used  to  pressing  their  own  culture  onto  others  and  taking  what  they   want   in   return.”   (Uwujaren   2013)   Starbucks’s   green   tea   latte   clearly   illustrates   a   case  of  Western  dominance  over  a  Japanese  cultural  object.       On   the   other   hand,   this   definition   extends   to   the   idea   that   one   can   also   exercise   appropriation   by   treating   marginalized   cultures   as   exotic   pastimes   to   be   experienced  and  then  quickly  forgotten.    Does  MatchaBar  exoticize  green  tea?  Unlike   Starbucks’s   green   tea   lattes,   the   case   of   MatchaBar   is   more   difficult   to   define.     Nevertheless,   the   one   thing   that   we   can   determine   from   this   is   that   the   Western   consumption   of   other   cultures   is   a   form   of   privilege.     “…Using   someone   else’s   cultural   symbols   to   satisfy   a   personal   need   for   self-­‐expression   is   an   exercise   in   privilege.”    (Uwujaren  2013)    Many  marginalized  cultures  do  not  have  the  luxury  to   enjoy  their  own  culture  without  being  stigmatized,  and  when  they  consume  Western   culture,  it  is  viewed  as  an  act  of  assimilation.
  • 36.   36   Retail  tea  shops   While   large   corporations   like   The   Coffee   Bean   and   Starbucks   diffuse   large   quantities   of   foreign   commodities   to   the   global   market,   mass   marketing   and   the   efficiency   of   pre-­‐made   beverages   can   often   dilute   the   very   authenticity   the   providers  advertise.    As  a  result,  consumers  delve  elsewhere  for  higher  quality  tea.         For  such  consumers,  retail  teashops  such  as  Teavana,  Ito  En,  and  Lupicia  are  the  best   destinations  for  the  real  tea  experience.    While  Teavana  is  an  American  brand,  Ito  En   and  Lupicia  are  both  originally  Japanese  enterprises.    By  purchasing  and  preparing   the  drink  themselves,  consumers  gain  greater  control  over  the  quality  and  supposed   authenticity  of  the  tea.    They  are  able  to  take  it  home  with  them  and  enjoy  it  in  the   comfort  of  their  private  space.    Sometimes,  in  order  to  truly  experience  the  tea,  they   even  learn  the  proper  way  to  prepare  it  and  purchase  the  traditional  bamboo  whisk.     As   a   result,   in   this   way,   a   commodity   also   seemingly   becomes   a   more   authentic   cultural  capital.       But  can  a  culture  completely  retain  its  original  form  when  it  has  been  sifted   through  the  global  market?    While  people  know  that  the  Ethiopians  were  the  first   people  to  develop  the  preparation  techniques  of  Arabica  coffee,  not  many  actually   replicate   their   elaborate   ceremony   or   their   etiquette.     And   even   as   consumers   accurately  execute  the  correct  steps  for  preparing  powdered  green  tea,  they  don’t   follow  any  of  the  prescribed  ceremonial  rituals  taught  in  Sado  that  inspire  Buddhist   philosophy.     Evoking   the   writings   of   Walter   Benjamin,   Russell   Cobb   argues   that   while  we  strive  to  retain  the  “aura”  that  the  original  artifact  inspires,  in  this  age  of   globalization   where   mechanical   reproduction   has   made   everything   into   a   copy,
  • 37.   37   where   everything   has   become   “packaged”,   true   authenticity   is   unattainable.       “Commodification—or  the  transformation  of  a  good  into  a  product  whose  value  is   determined   by   the   market—is   a   phenomenon   that   destroys   the   artifice   of   authenticity,  even  though  all  cultural  products  have  a  market  value”  (Cobb  2014:6).     As  in  cafés,  the  relationship  between  the  provider  and  the  consumer  in  a  retail  tea   shop   is   too   distant   for   any   kind   of   cultural   transaction   to   take   place.         Even   if   customers   purchase   the   bamboo   whisk,   commodification   has   inevitably   rendered   the  supposed  cultural  capital,  almost  accultural.   Sado  Tea  Houses     In  today’s  world  where  mechanical  production  has  degraded  the  authenticity   of   many   artifacts,   not   only   do   consumers   seek   a   commodity’s   authenticity   in   the   sense  of  high  quality,  they  also  sometimes  search  for  cultural  authenticity.    “Ever   since  the  advent  of  the  age  of  the  copy,  we  continue  to  demand  cultural  artifacts   that—following   Benjamin—occupy   a   unique   ‘presence   in   time   and   space   in   the   physical   world’”   (Cobb   2014:3).     While   consumers   hope   that   simply   possessing   a   symbol   can   transmit   its   culture,   they   cannot   truly   attempt   to   possess   culture €

Related Documents